LostYonder wrote on June 17, 2021 at 3:02 PM (edited on June 17, 2021 at 5:41 PM)

Sartre - takes you in circles

Bourdieu - ultimately just bourgeois leftism

Habermas - same - bourgeois leftism

I don't regret engaging the subaltern school, but it got stuck in the colonial critique and never really matured

_caspar_ wrote on June 19, 2021 at 2:57 PM

"I don't regret engaging the subaltern school, but it got stuck in the colonial critique and never really matured"

Im only vaguely aware of this school, but I wonder if theres anyone coming from this field of study who has ditched Marx's agents-of-history calling for sociopolitical integration of the subaltern and taken up a more anti-civ or anarchistic approach instead?

LostYonder wrote on June 21, 2021 at 2:31 PM

Not that I'm aware of - most of them chose high paying academic positions in the US and have been pacified. There were a few budding ones in India, but they were murdered early on for taking activist roles. Perhaps in Latin America there are some who have translated it into a more critical perspective, but I'm unaware.

In general there has been a rise of critical decolonization theory which takes on a more anti-civ perspective, but it seems mostly piecemeal...

lobby: Welcome to Raddle! The Forum for People

This is kind of a catch-all subforum, where you can dicuss things that would otherwise not fall into the other forums.

For example, you can introduce yourself, or your dog, or whatever.

Note that this is not for meta content. For that, check out /f/meta.

To donate to help with server costs, click here:

w/donate

Have fun!

10 Frequently Asked Questions About Raddle

Need to reuse a link/image embedding code many times in Markdown? Use variables!

If you have suggestions for the forum, a desire to change its look, or to become a moderator, please feel encouraged make a post about it in the forum or contact the moderator(s) directly.