Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

4

crimpsonchin wrote

I would say so yes. That is a reactionary answer, which ignores the possiblity of future rehablitation through therapy and chemical castration.

0

martasultan wrote

Some people are fucked up, period, and won't ever be rehabilitated; no Beria will ever be a proper, safe person. Sometimes a round is the best cure.

3

crimpsonchin wrote

okay but is that always a fair punishment for the crime? sure rape is bad, but an automatic death sentance seems harsh, also what about false accusations of crime?

1

PerfectSociety wrote

Your question doesn’t really make sense. Your asking as if we are proposing some kind of policy for how to deal with rapists. We aren’t. If people (perhaps the victim and/or her loved ones) are pissed off at a rapist, they might kill that rapist. Or they might torture the rapist. Or they might forcibly castrate the rapist. Or, they might forgive the rapist. Or they might do something I haven’t listed.

The point is that there are no laws that codify what is to be done with rapists. Neither is there any law that protects them from so-called “mob justice”. Laws don’t exist in Anarchy.

-1

martasultan wrote

sure rape is bad

This is something of an... understatement.

automatic death sentance seems harsh

Perhaps, then, don't rape a kid. That's a major fuckin' no-no.

also what about false accusations of crime?

I had assumed any proposed punishment was for those confirmed to have committed such. Generally I oppose punishment before that.

1

crimpsonchin wrote

evidence can be faked well keep in mind. Just look at how messed up the justice system now is.

Also you ignore that chemical castration CAN cure rapists.

2

ziq wrote

That's not true. Most rapists get off on power; chemical castration doesn't stop them from wanting to hurt people. It just stops them from getting erections.

1

martasultan wrote

Chemical castration only works if they stick to the drugs- they'll go right back to however they were before after, with maybe some side effects to fuck them up. That's not a solution feasible without an officer forcing them to keep the regime on.