Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

[deleted] wrote

Reply to comment by happy in Describe your utopia by AlexanderReidRoss

2

AlexanderReidRoss OP wrote

leaving people live with shit body, shit minds, and shit living envrionment

Comrade, you're coming off as either ableist or misanthropist depending on what you mean by this. Our minds and bodies aren't shit, and Earth isn't a shit living environment.

3

happy wrote

tbh your answer was low effort and condescending

You're not wrong, but thanks for the heated vocab in your first sentence.

Anything that creates social stratification is going to to create hierarchy, inevitably. This is a very common critique on various technologies. Am I for the abolishment of all forms of technology? Definitely not. Am I being critical of the technologies that are actively being created and maintained? Yes.

Proponents of capitalism argue that it gives possibilities to people and we both know how wrong that is in creating hierarchy. We currently have the choice to eschew technology but if someone wants to have a place in society they are coerced into using those technologies. Anarcho-transhumanism won't be any different. Just because it's under the guise of choice doesn't mean its actually free.

Being critical of technology is not actively choosing to letting people live with shit lifes. Anarchism should have absolute egalitarianism as a goal and creating technology that is going to create more social stratification is not egalitarian.

2