You must log in or register to comment.


Cheeks wrote

Try to get them to reveal identifying information. Dox 'em and let their communities and bosses sort 'em out.

When that's not possible, tell them goodbye and move on.


anarchist_critic wrote

So-called anarchists are really into relying on bosses to use their authority for our benefit? What is the world coming to?

The way I see it, there's three basic options. One: use it as a venting opportunity, call them some names and have a flame war. If possible, pwn them in the eyes of the audience by making them look stupid. If you're on the chans or similar sites then communication works rather like "the dozens": the "winner" is whoever tears down or provokes the other person without showing loss of cool themselves. With our history of Situationism and culture jamming, we should be way better at this than the fash, and it's pretty disturbing that we aren't right now. But, this isn't an option if you're easily triggered by whatever topics they're spewing on.

Two: ignore or block them, on the assumption they're doing it to get a reaction. This is the best response if you're dealing with someone who you suspect is not a literal fascist and is spouting fascist shit to get a reaction. This is also the best way to not get upset and not let them derail discussions or disrupt what are meant to be left or anarchist communities. The danger is that they just go troll somewhere else or get increasingly isolated and radicalised hanging out in fascist-only spaces, secure in the knowledge that they're "censored" and "silenced" everywhere else. It's also not an option if you're in an anonymous free-for-all space or a space where the mods won't ban them (some fash have got very clever about staying just inside the rules while also using dog-whistles that we and they recognise).

Three: try to talk them out of fascism. Here, you can either use nonviolent communication or rational argument. It occasionally works (see but not very often. IMO anarchists need to get a lot better at both rational argument and NVC, but its easier to hone the former than the latter on fascists because their logic is really shit and their tone is really aggressive. You have to be a fucking saint to use NVC with fash trolls because they know just how to get people's threat-perceptions sky-high, but I've seen reports of success from people like Marshall Rosenberg (who's Jewish) and Vishwam Jamie Heckert (who's gay) when dealing with far-right abuse. Another approach is to try to talk to them about the underlying grievances which manifest in their fascist politics - particularly, to talk about class politics and globalisation and how workers are exploited everywhere. I've found the last of these the most effective, even though it's not my go-to strategy as an egoist. Your average internet fascist is either a downwardly mobile, working-class or lower-middle-class white person from the American or European rustbelt, or an extremely marginalised shut-in who's effectively been forced out of public spaces by the very high levels of stress and anxiety. They have justified grievances but they're taking them out on the wrong people. The internet is actually a good place to talk to these people without the risk of getting punched. But, this isn't going to work if they're political entrepreneurs who are using far-right ideas manipulatively, or if they're a troll in the classic sense, who's saying offensive things for "the lulz". And you have to be able to stay calm when they start name-calling.


amongstclouds wrote

I like to say things that make them think I'm stupid so while they stroke their over inflated ego and getting their undies tied in a knot I'm over here sipping coffee and listening to good music!


therealmidnite wrote

Depends on the type of fash troll, really. I hate the Jordan Peterson-type clones. I've found that it's best to just antagonize the crap out of them right off the bat - whatever you do, don't try to "prove them wrong with facts". Acting dumb and asking nit-picking questions about every little thing they say can also work.


ziq wrote (edited )

Fash play this game where they try to demonstrate that 'leftists' are all these Alex Jones-informed stereotypes they have in their head... Like "AHA! SEE! COMMIE SJW SCREECHING CUCKS!!!"

Instead of giving them what they want, I respond by listing all the ways I'd like to murder them.

They don't come back after I do this because they're completely caught off guard.

They expect some well-kempt self-righteous ball of moral virtue that, unlike them, has to play by the rules of polite society. Instead, they get a hyper-masculine dirtbag that isn't fazed by their trolling and instead out-trolls them and leaves them whining about being oppressed. Effectively turning the tables on them and leaving them defeated and with no feeling of satisfaction for having 'triggered' me that would bring them back for another round.


rot wrote

This plays into the idea that you're nothing but a "violent antifa thug" if you do that outside of Raddle they'll be able to point an say see? I try to open a dialogue and these mean leftist threaten me! and the centrists and liberals all nod


ziq wrote (edited )


Liberals, centrists, fascists, all equally useless to me. Appealing to their shitty sensibilities is the last thing I'm interesting in doing.

Not that I would ever spend time in a liberal space.