Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

0

ziq wrote

Can the downvoters offer their reasoning please?

1

ergdj5 wrote

makhno killed fifty gorillion ukrainian jews and the kronstadt sailors were actually white russians

1

Cheeks wrote

Are you referring to the Ukrainian Nationalists, the Imperial German and Austro-German occupyers, the Hetmanate Republic, the Russian White Army, the Russian Red Army, or some other smaller forces led by Ukrainian otamans?

I'm honestly interested, cite please?

1

ziq wrote

It's good that anarchy isn't a personality cult defined by one self proclaimed anarchist then.

3

ergdj5 wrote

That was sarcasm, if it wasn't clear.

1

ziq wrote

Yeah I thought you were a little off on those facts.

4

ergdj5 wrote

Yeah, tankies often claim that 1. Makhno was anti-Semitic (he literally executed officers in his army who were anti-Semitic) and 2. The Kronstadt sailors were reactionary

3

ziq wrote

everyone tankies kill is 'reactionary' I guess. to them it just means 'not a tankie'.