Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments


mofongo wrote

That's a huge non-answer.


kore wrote (edited )

I think the point that Dumai was trying to make is that there's a huge difference between religious experience and organized religion and so-called religious anarchists find value in the former more than the latter.


Dumai wrote (edited )

more than that - religion doesn't necessarily have to treat the abstract as concrete, so it doesn't have to be alienating and is not inherently oppressive

in fact imo christianity has a better shot at overcoming its metaphysical trappings than atheistic materialism b/c it isn't as hard for it to admit that the categories it employs are not pre-discursive

not that it's easy for christians by any means


kore wrote

right, and I also think that by not treating the abstract as concrete you accept that pre-discursive experience can never be explained, and often religions do well by being unapologetic about that ineffability.


Dumai wrote

well what would you like me to go into more detail with?

it's tricky getting too detailed when talking about "religion" because that label is nowhere near a cultural universal and is actually pretty christian-centric, so if you want me to be more specific about christianity then i will.