Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Pash OP wrote (edited )

Reply to comment by OdiousOutlaw in Law and violence ≠ state by Pash

You don't have to mention anything, you didn't object to my comment about how large, sedentary societies mutate into states with anything to imply that you didn't want a sedentary society.

What I want is irrelevant; it's not like I'm some magic-wand-waver who can create entire societies by wishing.

Most societies have been patchworks of sedentism and nomadism. In North America, you find nomadic hunting tribes and sedentary people of the corn, and these two trade and intermarry. (Sedentary-in-winter-nomadic-in-summer is a pretty common pattern too.)

And since your whole back and forth with ziq really started because of your query about railways

The railways were an example; it was a query about coördinated action.

2